Location Sharing In a World of Many Options and Apps

I play with a lot of location products. The more of them I use, the more I get to understand how I think about sharing my own location with people I know and how those products fit into my life. As I’ve used more products, I’ve started to think about the dimensions along which I can classify products and their use cases. I’ve been really trying to wrap my head around the use case for products like Glympse and Twist, which allow me to let people know that I am en route and when I should arrive. It has taken me awhile to understand how they fit into my life and how and where they are valuable.

Before delving into Twist and Glympse, just a quick sense for how I think about the many location products I use. I can coarsely classify them along two core dimensions:

  • Persistent vs. Transient Relationships – For all location sharing applications, I try to think about whether I use the product to share my location with people with whom I have a persistent or a transient relationship.
  • Real-Time Sharing vs. Logging Location – Most of these products talk about location “sharing” but I tend to use some of them more as a log (where I’ve been over a long period of time) as opposed to sharing (this is where I am right now). To me, the difference is that the value of a location share decays quickly in environments where my past locations are not visible (Highlight) versus those where people can browse where I’ve been (foursquare and Facebook).

I can write a pretty short sentence about most products I use and how I use them based on the framework above:

  • I use foursquare (and Path) to share my current location frequently with a smallish group of people with whom I have persistent relationships. I also use it as a log over time.
  • I use Highlight to share my recent location with a fairly large group of friends and friends-of-friends with whom I have both transient and persistent relationships.
  • I use Facebook to share my current location with a large group of people with whom I have persistent relationships for those rare location shares that I think are noteworthy or of interest to many people.
  • I use Twitter to share my current location with a large group of people with whom I have transient or loose relationships for those rare location shares that I think are noteworthy or of interest to many people.

With those four services, I felt like most of my social needs for location sharing were met. When I was first introduced to Twist and Glympse, I was having a hard time finding a gap in the current suite of products I use. I’ve been using both for about a month or two and I can finally articulate how they work for me:

I use Twist to share my current (and future) location with people with whom I have both persistent and transient relationships.

I mostly use Twist these days, but I can say that it does things that I can’t easily do with any of the other options. It’s a pretty useful way to let people know when I’m en route and to have them do the same.

The biggest problem I have with Twist is that most people to whom I’ve sent a Twist have never received one before. So they are discovering the app for the first time and that can be a bit socially awkward. If I knew that more people were using Twist, I’d be more inclined to send them. I’ve gotten a fair number of “what is this?” messages from people – it’s pretty easy to explain after the fact.

Overall, even in what I think of as a crowded category, I still find products that fill unoccupied niches. I like Twist and Glympse and I think there’s a need for these products. I think the biggest risk they face is that the big calendar applications or Google Now / Siri offer this as native functionality.

I’m curious as to how you use location-sharing apps. Feel free to leave a comment below or send me a message on Twitter @chudson.

  • http://twitter.com/insetinc Inset, Inc.

    As always food for thought.

  • http://twitter.com/semil Semil

    I’m impressed at how precisely you slice all of these use cases. End of the day, I am not sure if most people want to have their battery drained with location tracking in the background, nor do they want to actively and explicitly check-in all the time, even if there are “offers.” For the power user like you, there are endless choices, but I only see 2-3 winners emerging: http://techcrunch.com/2012/05/08/why-location-based-services-will-create-multiple-winners-at-the-application-layer/

  • http://nathan.dintenfass.com ndintenfass

    Agree on the distinctions between logging/notifying and wide/narrow groups (begging for a 2×2 graphic!). The Apple “Find Friends” app has filled a niche for me not really covered in your post — letting the tiny group of people who may need to know where I am all the time know where I am. Right now that’s just 2 people, but before it we had tried Glympse and Latitude and a couple others, and they were all cumbersome, at best. Foursquare acts as the log for me, though I find I only actually check in these days when I can think of at least one person that would be interested to know that I’m at a give place (often a different person depending on the place). By the way there’s a nice iOS app called Checkie that makes Foursquare checkins extra simple. I never cared for using Facebook or Twitter for location sharing, as that feels like an overloading of what those services are for (and seems like noise to most of the people who follow me there). When I first started using Path I was being more active with pure location sharing, but after a while I found that only when I had a good picture to share did I bother putting in the location. As I’ve played with Vine it has been interesting to note when I do and don’t want to add the location (usually when the location would provide some context to the viewer of the video). Off to download Twist now…

  • Pingback: LOCATION APPS » Location Sharing In a World of Many Options and Apps | Charles …()

  • https://www.saglikhocasi.com

    As always food for thought.

  • TouQeeR KinG

    Great write up, bookmarked the blog in hopes to see more information!

    Cccam Server | Cardsharing | Cardsharing Server | Dreambox Cccam | Dreambox Cardsharing

  • Sebastian

    Oh boy Charles, do I have an app you’ll love.

    It’s called PLANiT, persistent and transient relationships live side-by-side, anybody can interact, viral model, location known through shared events on schedule, cross-platform for group chat and easier coordination, and is coming out in July to set a new standard for Silicon Valley. Would love to partner with you to outdo the largest companies (Google, Microsoft, Facebook) so I will keep trying to connect. You will regret it if you pass this one up!

  • Pingback: Lessons Learned from Sharing Twist With My Network | Charles Hudson's Weblog()